| Episode # |
Original Air Date |
Titles |
| |
| Season 1 |
| |
| 1. | 1-1 | 03 Sep 13 | Small Town Suicide? (Cuero, TX) |
| 2. | 1-2 | 10 Sep 13 | Mother (Morehouse Parish, LA) |
| 3. | 1-3 | 17 Sep 13 | Home Town Hero (Palacios, TX) |
| 4. | 1-4 | 24 Sep 13 | Hit and Run (Globe, AZ) |
| 5. | 1-5 | 01 Oct 13 | Hiding in Plain Sight (Dickson County, TN) |
| 6. | 1-6 | 08 Oct 13 | Small Town Tragedy (Thatcher, AZ) |
| 7. | 1-7 | 15 Oct 13 | Hatchet (Sandusky County, OH) |
| 8. | 1-8 | 22 Oct 13 | Blind Love (Gaines County, TX) |
| |
| Season 2 |
| |
| 9. | 2-1 | 17 Jan 14 | Gone (Altus, OK) |
| 10. | 2-2 | 24 Jan 14 | A Monster Among Us (Camp Hill, AL) |
| 11. | 2-3 | 31 Jan 14 | High School Sweethearts (La Porte, TX) |
| 12. | 2-4 | 07 Feb 14 | First Love (Cottonwood, AZ) |
| 13. | 2-5 | 14 Feb 14 | He Said, He Said (Vigo County, IN) |
| 14. | 2-6 | 21 Feb 14 | Ambush (Malvern, AR) |
| 15. | 2-7 | 28 Feb 14 | Single Working Mom (Gallatin, TN) |
| 16. | 2-8 | 07 Mar 14 | Billy Goat Hill (Chattanooga, TN) |
| 17. | 2-9 | 14 Mar 14 | Lady in the Box (Aurora, CO) |
| 18. | 2-10 | 28 Mar 14 | Copper Dollar Ranch (Jasper, IA) |
| 19. | 2-11 | 20 Jun 14 | Stranded (Bay City, TX) |
| 20. | 2-12 | 27 Jun 14 | Death by Design? (Waller County, TX) |
| 21. | 2-13 | 11 Jul 14 | Kirby's Speed Shop (Columbus, GA) |
| 22. | 2-14 | 25 Jul 14 | Sunspot Highway (Alamogordo, NM) |
| 23. | 2-15 | 01 Aug 14 | Other Side of the Tracks (Cambridge, OH) |
| 24. | 2-16 | 08 Aug 14 | Second Thoughts (Paulding, OH) |
| 25. | 2-17 | 15 Aug 14 | Fool Me Once, Fool Me Twice? (Vigo County, IN) |
| |
| Season 3 |
| |
| 26. | 3-1 | 09 Jan 15 | Still of the Night (Pocatello, ID) |
| 27. | 3-2 | 16 Jan 15 | Miss Congeniality (Yakima County, WA) |
| 28. | 3-3 | 23 Jan 15 | Burned (Fairview Park, OH) |
| 29. | 3-4 | 30 Jan 15 | Mother Daughter Tragedy (Fort Wayne, IN) |
| 30. | 3-5 | 06 Feb 15 | Operator, Hurry! (St. Johns County, FL) |
| 31. | 3-6 | 20 Feb 15 | The Record Keeper (Bridgeport, WV) |
| 32. | 3-7 | 27 Feb 15 | Little League Dad (Arlington, TX) |
| 33. | 3-8 | 06 Mar 15 | American Dream (Fort Myers, FL) |
| 34. | 3-9 | 10 Apr 15 | The Alley (Hialeah, FL) |
| 35. | 3-10 | 17 Apr 15 | Devoted (Okaloosa, FL) |
| 36. | 3-11 | 24 Apr 15 | Lying in Wait (Greenville, OH) |
| 37. | 3-12 | 01 May 15 | Trip to Nowhere (Hernando County, FL) |
| 38. | 3-13 | 15 May 15 | Beloved Doctor (Paducah, KY) |
| 39. | 3-14 | 29 May 15 | Smoking Gun (Cleveland, TN) |
| 40. | 3-15 | 05 Jun 15 | The Good Life (West Palm Beach, FL) |
| 41. | 3-16 | 31 Jul 15 | Off the Beaten Path (Spartanburg, SC) |
| 42. | 3-17 | 07 Aug 15 | Room #10 (Fort Myers, FL) |
| 43. | 3-18 | 14 Aug 15 | The Escape? (Oregon County, MO) |
| 44. | 3-19 | 21 Aug 15 | Up in Flames (Johnson County, IA) |
| 45. | 3-20 | 28 Aug 15 | Trajectory (Taylor County, WV) |
| 46. | 3-21 | 11 Sep 15 | In the Neighborhood, Part 1 (White Settlement, TX) |
| 47. | 3-22 | 18 Sep 15 | In the Neighborhood, Part 2 (White Settlement, TX) |
| |
| Season 4 |
| |
| 48. | 4-1 | 22 Jul 17 | One of Our Own |
| 49. | 4-2 | 29 Jul 17 | Fresh Wounds |
| 50. | 4-3 | 05 Aug 17 | A Deadly Inheritance |
| 51. | 4-4 | 12 Aug 17 | Beyond the Grave |
| 52. | 4-5 | 19 Aug 17 | Home Alone |
| 53. | 4-6 | 02 Sep 17 | The Widow |
| 54. | 4-7 | 09 Sep 17 | If I Can't Have You, No One Can |
| 55. | 4-8 | 23 Sep 17 | Cabin in the Woods |
| 56. | 4-9 | 30 Sep 17 | Dying Declaration |
| 57. | 4-10 | 28 Oct 17 | Covet |
| |
| Season 5 |
| |
| 58. | 5-1 | 04 Aug 18 | Small Town Secrets |
| 59. | 5-2 | 11 Aug 18 | The Professor's End |
| 60. | 5-3 | 18 Aug 18 | Holding Onto Hope |
| 61. | 5-4 | 25 Aug 18 | Down by the Lake |
| 62. | 5-5 | 01 Sep 18 | Danger at Dawn |
| 63. | 5-6 | 08 Sep 18 | Preacher's Mother |
| 64. | 5-7 | 15 Sep 18 | No Safe Return |
| 65. | 5-8 | 22 Sep 18 | Bound and Burnt |
| 66. | 5-9 | 29 Sep 18 | Pain in Pawhuska |
| 67. | 5-10 | 06 Oct 18 | The Case Behind the Billboards (90 min) |
| 68. | 5-11 | 16 Feb 19 | Death Among Him, Part 1 |
| 69. | 5-12 | 23 Feb 19 | Death Among Him, Part 2 |
| 70. | 5-13 | 02 Mar 19 | Backwater Bloodshed |
| 71. | 5-14 | 09 Mar 19 | Golden Years Gone |
| 72. | 5-15 | 16 Mar 19 | A Mother's Dying Wish |
| 73. | 5-16 | 23 Mar 19 | Texas Tragedy |
| 74. | 5-17 | 30 Mar 19 | Family Betrayal |
| 75. | 5-18 | 06 Apr 19 | Horror in the Home |
| 76. | 5-19 | 14 Mar 20 | Valentine's Day Violence |
| 77. | 5-20 | 21 Mar 20 | Small Town Predator |
| 78. | 5-21 | 28 Mar 20 | Mystery on the Mountain |
| 79. | 5-22 | 04 Apr 20 | Double Life Discovered |
| 80. | 5-23 | 11 Apr 20 | Digging for Answers |
| 81. | 5-24 | 18 Apr 20 | Deadly Affairs |
| 82. | 5-25 | 25 Apr 20 | A Family's Nightmare |
| 83. | 5-26 | 02 May 20 | Fatal Betrayal |
| |
| Season 6 |
| |
| 84. | 6-1 | 10 Jul 21 | Holiday Homicide |
| 85. | 6-2 | 17 Jul 21 | Deadly Premonition |
| 86. | 6-3 | 24 Jul 21 | A Touch of Evidence |
| 87. | 6-4 | 31 Jul 21 | Unnatural Causes |
| 88. | 6-5 | 06 Nov 21 | An Officer's Promise |
| 89. | 6-6 | 13 Nov 21 | Out in the Cold |
| 90. | 6-7 | 20 Nov 21 | A Desperate Father |
| 91. | 6-8 | 27 Nov 21 | Small Town Conspiracy (90 min) |
| 92. | 6-9 | 04 Dec 21 | Sitting Through the Ashes |
| 93. | 6-10 | 11 Dec 21 | Victim or Villain? |
| 94. | 6-11 | 18 Dec 21 | Father's Day Massacre |
| 95. | 6-12 | 01 Jan 22 | Three Generations Gone |
| 96. | 6-13 | 03 Sep 22 | A Mother's Last Words (90 min) |
| 97. | 6-14 | 10 Sep 22 | Shot in the Dark |
| 98. | 6-15 | 17 Sep 22 | Dangerous Rendezvous |
| 99. | 6-16 | 24 Sep 22 | For Love or Money? |
| 100. | 6-17 | 01 Oct 22 | The Key to the Crime, Part 1 |
| 101. | 6-18 | 08 Oct 22 | The Key to the Crime, Part 2 |
| 102. | 6-19 | 25 Feb 23 | Burning Mystery |
| 103. | 6-20 | 04 Mar 23 | Double Disappearance |
| 104. | 6-21 | 11 Mar 23 | Trail of Terror |
| 105. | 6-22 | 18 Mar 23 | On Holy Grounds |
| 106. | 6-23 | 25 Mar 23 | Deadly Abduction |
| 107. | 6-24 | 01 Apr 23 | Digging for Justice |
| |
| Season 7 |
| |
| 108. | 7-1 | 24 Feb 24 | Beloved Veteran |
| 109. | 7-2 | 02 Mar 24 | Silenced |
| 110. | 7-3 | 09 Mar 24 | Killer at the Door |
| 111. | 7-4 | 16 Mar 24 | Enemy Next Door |
| 112. | 7-5 | 23 Mar 24 | Some Kind of Monster |
| 113. | 7-6 | 30 Mar 24 | The Reporter |
| 114. | 7-7 | 06 Apr 24 | Stolen Beauty |
| 115. | 7-8 | 13 Apr 24 | Stabbed in the Heart |
| 116. | 7-9 | 20 Apr 24 | Bound and Gagged |
| 117. | 7-10 | 27 Apr 24 | House of Horrors (Part 1) |
| 118. | 7-11 | 04 May 24 | House of Horrors (Part 2) |
| 119. | 7-12 | 11 May 24 | From Loss to Light: A Cold Justice Update Special |
| |
| Season 8 |
| |
| 120. | 8-1 | 13 Sep 25 | Newlywed Nightmare |
| 121. | 8-2 | 20 Sep 25 | Road to Nowhere |
| 122. | 8-3 | 27 Sep 25 | Mountain of Secrets |
| 123. | 8-4 | 04 Oct 25 | Final Warning |
| 124. | 8-5 | 11 Oct 25 | Deadly Message |
| 125. | 8-6 | 18 Oct 25 | A Mother's Nightmare |
| 126. | 8-7 | 25 Oct 25 | Life Cut Short |
| 127. | 8-8 | 01 Nov 25 | Final Rendezvous |
| 128. | 8-9 | 08 Nov 25 | Deadly Intersection |
| 129. | 8-10 | 15 Nov 25 | Missing in Montana |
| |
| Specials |
| |
| S08. | 8-0 | 22 Nov 25 | Inside the Investigation 801 |
| S02. | 2-0 | 18 Jul 14 | Justice Served (Los Angeles, CA) |
| S03. | 3-0 | 08 May 15 | Justice Served (Los Angeles, CA) |
| S03. | 3-0 | 04 Sep 15 | Justice Served (Los Angeles, CA) |
| |